Why Clinical Mistakes in Optometry Are Your Best Teachers

Skip to main content
Practical learning · A little support for life in eye care.Member sign in

Optometry support · Reflection · Clinical confidence

Why clinical mistakes in optometry
are your best teachers.

A personal reflection on learning from a difficult clinic, with practical guidance for optometrists looking for support and for students, pre-reg trainees and CLiP students finding their feet.

We spend years anchored in the safety of theory, devouring textbooks, memorising pathologies, and sitting through endless lectures. Theory is comfortable because every patient follows the exact rules of the page. But the moment you step into a real-life clinic, you realise the environment is dynamic and entirely unpredictable.

Real patients haven’t read the textbooks. When the standard routine fails, the fear of making clinical mistakes in optometry can feel utterly paralysing. But looking back at my own journey, those exact moments of failure were the catalysts for my deepest professional growth.

The Textbook Trap and Clinical Mistakes in Optometry

When we are starting out, there is a strong temptation to rely on pre-determined judgements. You might see a receptionist’s note that reads “patient thinks they have conjunctivitis,” and your brain immediately starts ticking through the textbook treatment for a red eye.

But the real world demands we think outside the box. That same patient might actually be a contact lens wearer with poor hygiene habits, presenting a much more complex clinical picture than a simple surface infection.

Relying purely on theory often leads to clinical mistakes in optometry because we stop looking at the person in the chair and start looking at the expected diagnosis. Real-life practice requires the humility to realise that overconfidence is frequently the first step toward a clinical blind spot.

A Lesson from the Pre-Reg Year

I remember a specific moment from my own pre-reg year that stays with me to this day. It was a classic autopilot error. I was navigating through the history and symptoms routine with a patient who had explicitly informed me earlier in the conversation that they were adopted and knew nothing about their biological family. A few minutes later, I reached the family history section of my routine and automatically asked about their parents’ eye health.

The patient rightly pointed out that I clearly was not applying the information they had just shared to my question set. I was obtaining data, but I wasn’t processing it dynamically. I felt incredibly uncomfortable, much like a broken magnifying glass, but that error taught me more about the importance of active listening than any lecture on communication ever could. It was one of those clinical mistakes in optometry that fundamentally changed how I practise, and I have never made that exact error again.

The Reality of Clinical Paralysis

For students, pre-regs, and even experienced clinicians, the pressure to be perfect is immense. The fear of failing an OSCE, facing the GOC, or simply getting something “wrong” can lead to clinical paralysis.

We are terrified of making clinical mistakes in optometry because we care deeply about our patients, and we carry a professional Duty of Candour to be honest when things go wrong.2

But here is the truth: we are human. We all make clinical mistakes in optometry and in every area of our lives. In the testing room, how we respond to these errors is an important part of mastering our craft.

If you think a patient’s care may have been affected, seek appropriate clinical advice and take action within the timescale the situation requires. Follow your practice’s incident process and record the relevant actions. Involve your supervisor if you are training. The GOC’s candour guidance explains when and how to tell the patient what has happened, apologise and help put matters right. Your indemnity provider or professional body can advise if you are unsure how to proceed.12

Transforming Clinical Mistakes in Optometry into Mastery

Whether it is a heuristic bias that influenced a decision or a genuine gap in your knowledge that needs addressing, clinical mistakes in optometry are the tallest bar on our learning chart because they stick. Learning from them can refine our clinical judgement and help us become safer practitioners.3 If you have failed an exam or had a clinic day where you felt you got it wrong, do not let that doubt consume you. Use it.

You cannot be perfect 100% of the time; you can only aim to be better than you were yesterday. The university and pre-reg/CLiP stages give you the support of supervisors to help you recognise errors, respond appropriately and guide your learning.5 If you’re working through what happened with a supervisor or colleague, here’s how to use constructive feedback.

The Path to Clinical Confidence

Embrace the learning process. The most seasoned clinicians are not the ones who never made any clinical mistakes in optometry; they are the ones who learned the most from them.

Navigating the complexities of our profession is demanding, and you do not have to carry the weight of your clinical development alone. If you are looking for a supportive environment to refine your skills and discuss clinical mistakes in optometry safely, come and join us at The Eye Care Advocate Community platform. You will find these ‘Points of Light’ style posts waiting for you inside, designed to encourage and elevate your daily practice.

Keep patient-identifiable information out of community discussions and learning notes. Use your practice’s approved clinical advice routes for individual patient care.4

Explore The Eye Care Advocate Community ↗

Questions about mistakes, confidence and support

What should I do if I think I have made a clinical mistake in optometry?

Seek appropriate clinical advice and address any effect on the patient’s care within the required timescale. Follow your practice’s incident process and document the relevant actions. Students, pre-reg trainees and CLiP students should involve their supervisor. Use the GOC’s duty of candour guidance where it applies.12

Who can an optometrist turn to for support after a difficult clinic?

A suitable clinical colleague can help you work through uncertainty about patient care. Your indemnity provider or professional body can advise about complaints or professional concerns. For emotional support, the AOP Peer Support Line is available to members and non-members. The Eye Care Advocate Community offers further learning resources and opportunities to connect.6

How can I reflect on a mistake without getting stuck replaying it?

After dealing with any action needed for patient care, describe what happened, consider the contributing factors and choose a specific change. Discuss it with an appropriate colleague or supervisor if you need help deciding what to do next. Reflection is most useful when you can act on it.

Will a mistake during pre-reg or CLiP stop me from qualifying?

The implications depend on what happened and the requirements of your training route. Speak to your supervisor and training provider about the event, any action required and your learning needs. They can explain the relevant assessment and progression arrangements.

Can I discuss a patient’s case in the community?

Use your practice’s approved clinical advice routes for an individual patient. Community discussion should focus on general learning and professional experiences, with patient-identifiable information kept out. Removing a name alone may leave someone identifiable through other details.4

Where can I find optometry resources to improve my clinical confidence?

The Open Skill Centre includes free guides and simulator demonstrations. Further courses, simulators, calculators and Points of Light reflections are available in The Eye Care Advocate Community. Use them alongside appropriate teaching, supervision and professional guidance.

What is the message behind this article?

An uncomfortable experience can prompt useful learning when you respond to the patient’s needs, ask for appropriate support and make a change. Jason’s pre-reg story illustrates how a moment of going through the motions changed his approach to listening and history taking.

References and professional guidance

These sources support the professional guidance in this article. The pre-reg story and wider reflections are my own experiences and perspective.

  1. General Optical Council (2025). Standards of Practice, standard 7. Conduct appropriate assessments, examinations, treatments and referrals. Read source.
  2. General Optical Council. The professional duty of candour. Read source.
  3. General Optical Council (2025). Standards of Practice, standard 5. Keep your knowledge and skills up to date. Read source.
  4. General Optical Council. Disclosing confidential information. Read source.
  5. General Optical Council (2025). Standards for Optical Students. See standards 5, 6, 8 and 18 on competence, supervision and responding when things go wrong. Read source.
  6. Association of Optometrists. Peer Support Line. Read source.

Comments

Leave a Reply