When a child needs to start wearing an eye patch, finding a way to make it feel like less of a medical device and more of an adventure can be a game-changer. The Patch by Justina Chen Headley uses this exact approach, turning the experience into a catalyst for imaginative play. This kids book about amblyopia patching champions creativity as the ultimate tool for acceptance.

What is “The Patch” About?

The story follows Becca, a young girl who, after a visit to the “eye doctor,” finds out she needs glasses and an eye patch to help with her amblyopia. Initially upset and worried about what the kids at school will think, her perspective shifts when her brother suggests her patch makes her look like a pirate. Becca embraces this idea, arriving at school and leading her friends on a series of imaginative adventures where her patch becomes a key accessory for her roles as a swashbuckling pirate, a super sleuth, and a one-eyed monster.

Eye Care Themes in This Book

This book uses a narrative approach to cover several important topics:

The Eye Test: It includes a visit to the optometrist and a child-friendly description of blurry letters and the reason for an eye test.

Amblyopia Explained: It clearly explains that the patch is needed to help a “weaker” eye get stronger.

Coping Through Creativity: The central theme is using imagination and role-play to transform the patch from a medical necessity into a fun prop.

Navigating Social Questions: The story directly tackles the “why do you wear a patch?” questions from peers.

Jason’s View on “The Patch”

From my view as an optometrist, this book offers some excellent educational elements. I appreciate the clear explanation of amblyopia and how the patch works to strengthen the weaker eye. The initial visit to the “eye doctor” also helps to demystify the process. The core concept of empowering a child to make the patch part of their identity through play is a fantastic strategy for encouraging compliance with the patch wear.

However, I have some reservations. The book is American, so UK readers will notice terms like “eye doctor” and “recess”, which may be unfamiliar to them. More significantly, it starts with a very negative tone, which may not be helpful for a child who isn’t already feeling resistant. It also introduces potentially limiting ideas, like the main character thinking “ballerinas can’t wear patches,” which might plant a seed of doubt that wasn’t there before. My biggest concern is the reliance on stereotypes like “pirate” and “one-eyed monster.” While used positively here, these tropes can be unhelpful in the long run.

Additionally, the front cover shows Becca wearing a patch and glasses, but the glasses are not being worn correctly, which may portray a bad habit for the child reading the book.

As a parent, I love the beautiful illustrations by Mitch Vane, which are wonderfully energetic and reminiscent of Quentin Blake’s style in Roald Dahl’s books. The story is a good length for a slightly older child (perhaps 5-7) and the way it encourages creative problem-solving is a real strength.

That said, some social aspects of the story gave me pause. The narrative features a lot of other children asking Becca why she wears a patch. While her imaginative answers are clever, the constant questioning could make a real-world child anxious about facing a similar barrage. My main concern is the ending, where the teacher asks Becca to “tell us the real reason” she wears the patch in front of the class. While intended to be a moment of honest sharing, it could easily feel like being singled out and put on the spot, which would have horrified me as a child and would certainly concern me for my own son if he was put in the same situation without volunteering.

What Do Other Parents Think?

This book has a strong average rating of 4.6 stars on Amazon but a more moderate 3.9 on Goodreads, reflecting a split in opinion. Many parents call it a “much-loved” book that was instrumental in helping their child accept their patch without fuss. The creative, imaginative approach is frequently praised.

However, negative reviews echo my own concerns. Several readers found the initial negativity unhelpful and felt the story was too old for their pre-schoolers. The use of “pirate” and “one-eyed monster” stereotypes was a significant issue for some, who felt there were better, more modern books available.

Final Verdict

The Patch is a book best suited for an imaginative, slightly older child (5-7 years old) who might be struggling with the social aspect of wearing a patch. Its strength lies in offering a creative playbook for turning a potential source of anxiety into a fun game. However, parents should be mindful of the initial negativity and the potentially awkward classroom scenario at the end. It’s a useful tool, but one that may require a conversation with your child to frame it in the most positive light.

Ready to read it yourself? You can purchase “The Patch” on Amazon by clicking the link below.

As an Amazon Associate, I may earn a commission on any purchases through this link. All earnings help with the running of The Eye Care Advocate.

Return to Children’s Book Reviews

If you have found this review helpful, please consider sharing the page or The Eye Care Advocate with your friends, colleagues or children’s communities.